What are the problems with systemd?
Hey guys, I have been using a Linux for a while and I always thought as long as some software is Open Source, its good enough.
What are other considerations that make for good FOSS software? In which of these does systemd fail? Is that why it's criticized or is there some other reason?


Arcanoloth
in reply to eviley3 • • •No systemd - Resources against systemd and alternatives
nosystemd.orgShimitar
in reply to eviley3 • • •Probably rage bait.
Anyway, I like the simplicity of OpenRC and prefer it over systemd. After many years, I never had a reason to switch my Gentoo boxes (servers, laptops, etc) over.
I use systemd at work too, and it always feel unnecessarily complicated and that fixes issues I never had.
Whatever fit your bills I guess. Choice is good, so I am happily applying my choices with OpenRC.
eldavi
in reply to eviley3 • • •systemd is only used to initiate booting of a system afaik and, in the past, it was criticized for overreach (as in it did more than its predecessor did).
now-a-days, it seems to be criticized for pre-complying with big brother like laws like age verification.
Arcanoloth
in reply to eldavi • • •eldavi
in reply to Arcanoloth • • •you must have missed this part:
Arcanoloth
in reply to eldavi • • •𝘋𝘪𝘳𝘬
in reply to eviley3 • • •fozid
in reply to eviley3 • • •I don't think there is a problem with it. It's a piece of software that people can choose to use if it fits their specific use case. It has a long list of features and abilities, and lots of people find it sufficient for what they want.
There are also a lot of people that don't find it suitable for what they want and they can choose to not use systemd and use some other options.
I personally don't use systemd. I have used it for a while, originally I used sys v for a long time, then arch adopted systemd, I tried to get used to it and understand it but never felt comfortable with it, so I moved to void Linux which uses runit plus other items to replace systemd, and I feel a lot more comfortable and happy with this.
You do your research and testing and find what fits your use case.
Dingaling
in reply to eviley3 • • •