BTC Balances on the Brink as Traders Await Key Macro Events - Bitcoin sits at a decisive crossroads, balancing between critical technical levels and po... - cryptodaily.co.uk/2025/08/btc-… #morenews

XRP Price Prediction: Can Bullish Patterns and Whale Demand Offset the Recent Dip? - XRP is trading at $2.82, with a daily volume of $3.19 billion and a market cap of ... - cryptonews.com/news/xrp-price-… #cryptocurrency #priceanalysis #xrp

Top Blockchain PR Agency Guide 2025: Who Delivers Results - The blockchain industry has matured rapidly, but one thing hasn’t changed: projects live ... - cryptodaily.co.uk/2025/08/top-… #morenews

Is it possible to allow sideloading and keep users safe?

Link: shkspr.mobi/blog/2025/08/is-it…
Discussion: news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4…


Is it possible to allow sideloading *and* keep users safe?


shkspr.mobi/blog/2025/08/is-it…

In which I attempt to be pragmatic.

Are you allowed to run whatever computer program you want on the hardware you own? This is a question where freedom, practicality, and reality all collide into a mess.

Google has recently announced that Android users will only be able to install apps which have been digitally signed by developers who have registered their name and other legal details with Google. To many people, this signals the death of "sideloading" - the ability to install apps which don't originate on the official store0.

I'm a fully paid-up member of the Cory Doctorow fanclub. Back in 2011, he gave a speech called "The Coming War on General Computation". In it, he rails against the idea that our computers could become traitorous; serving the needs of someone other than their owner. Do we want to live in a future where our computers refuse to obey our commands? No! Neither law nor technology should conspire to reduce our freedom to compute.

There are, I think, two small cracks in that argument.

The first is that a user has no right to run anyone else's code, if the code owner doesn't want to make it available to them. Consider a bank which has an app. When customers are scammed, the bank is often liable. The bank wants to reduce its liability so it says "you can't run our app on a rooted phone".

Is that fair? Probably not. Rooting allows a user to fully control and customise their device. But rooting also allows malware to intercept communications, send commands, and perform unwanted actions. I think the bank has the right to say "your machine is too risky - we don't want our code to run on it."

The same is true of video games with strong "anti-cheat" protection. It is disruptive to other players - and to the business model - if untrustworthy clients can disrupt the game. Again, it probably isn't fair to ban users who run on permissive software, but it is a rational choice by the manufacturer. And, yet again, I think software authors probably should be able to restrict things which cause them harm.

So, from their point of view it is pragmatic to insist that their software can only be loaded from a trustworthy location.

But that's not the only thing Google is proposing. Let's look at their announcement:

We’ve seen how malicious actors hide behind anonymity to harm users by impersonating developers and using their brand image to create convincing fake apps. The scale of this threat is significant: our recent analysis found over 50 times more malware from internet-sideloaded sources than on apps available through Google Play.


Back in the early days of Android, you could just install any app and it would run, no questions asked. That was a touchingly naïve approach to security - extremely easy to use but left users vulnerable.

A few years later, Android changed to show user the permissions an app was requesting. Here's a genuine screenshot from an app which I tried to sideload in 2013:

A terrifying list of permissions.

No rational user would install a purported battery app with that scary list of permissions, right? Wrong!

We know that users don't read and they especially don't read security warnings.

There is no UI tweak you can do to prevent users bypassing these scary warnings. There is no amount of education you can provide to reliably make people stop and think.

Here's the story of a bank literally telling a man he was being scammed and he still proceeded to transfer funds to a fraudster.

It emerged that, in this case, Lloyds had done a really good job of not only spotting the potential fraud but alerting James to it. The bank blocked a number of transactions, it spoke to James on the phone to warn him and even called him into a branch to speak to him face-to-face.


Here's another one where a victim deliberately lied to their bank even after acknowledging that they had been told it was a scam.

Android now requires you to deliberately turn on the ability to side-load. It will give you prompts and warnings, force you to take specific actions, give you pop-ups and all sorts of confirmation steps.

And people still click on.

Let's go back to Google announcement. This change isn't being rolled out worldwide immediately. They say:

This change will start in a few select countries specifically impacted by these forms of fraudulent app scams, often from repeat perpetrators.

September 2026: These requirements go into effect in Brazil, Indonesia, Singapore, and Thailand. At this point, any app installed on a certified Android device in these regions must be registered by a verified developer.


The police in Singapore have a page warning about the prevalence of these scams. They describe how victims are tricked or coerced into turning off all their phone's security features.

Similarly, there are estimates that Brazil lost US$54 billion to scams in 2024 (albeit not all through apps).

There are anecdotal reports from Indonesia which show how easily people fall for these fake apps.

Thailand is also under an ongoing onslaught of malicious apps with some apps raking in huge amounts of money.

It is absolutely rational that government, police, and civic society groups want to find ways to stop these scams.

Google is afraid that if Android's reputation is tarnished as the "Scam OS" then users will move to more secure devices.

Financial institutions might stop providing functionality to Android devices as a way to protect their customers. Which would lead to those users seeking alternate phones.

Society as a whole wants to protect vulnerable people. We all bear the cost of dealing with criminal activity like this.

Given that sideloaded Android apps are clearly a massive vector for fraud, it obviously behoves Google to find a way to secure their platform as much as possible.

And Yet…


This is quite obviously a bullshit powerplay by Google to ensnare the commons. Not content with closing down parts of the Android Open Source Project, stuffing more and more vital software behind its proprietary services, and freezing out small manufacturers - now it wants the name and shoe-size of every developer!

Fuck that!

I want to use my phone to run the code that I write. I want to run my friends' code. I want to play with cool open source projects by people in far-away lands.

I remember The Day Google Deleted Me - we cannot have these lumbering monsters gatekeeping what we do on our machines.

Back in the days when I was a BlackBerry developer, we had to wait ages for RIM's code-signing server to become available. I'm pretty sure the same problem affected Symbian - if Nokia was down that day, you couldn't release any code.

Going back to their statement:

To be clear, developers will have the same freedom to distribute their apps directly to users through sideloading or to use any app store they prefer.


This is a lie. I can only distribute a sideloaded app if Google doesn't nuke my account. If I piss off someone there, or they click the wrong button, or they change the requirements so I'm no longer eligible - my content disappears.

They promise that Android will still be open to student and hobbyist developers - but would you believe anything those monkey-punchers say? Oh, and what a fricking insult to call a legion of Open Source developers "hobbyists"!

I hate it.

I also don't see how this is going to help. I guess if scammers all use the same ID, then it'll be easy for Android to super-nuke all the scam apps.

Perhaps when you install a sideloaded app you'll see "This app was made by John Smith - not a company. Here's his photo. Got any complaints? Call his number."

But what's going to happen is that people will get their IDs stolen, or be induced to register as a developer and then sign some malware. They'll also be victims.

So What's The Solution?


I've tried to be pragmatic, but there's something of a dilemma here.

  1. Users should be free to run whatever code they like.
  2. Vulnerable members of society should be protected from scams.

Do we accept that a megacorporation should keep everyone safe at the expense of a few pesky nerds wanting to run some janky code?

Do we say that the right to run free software is more important than granny being protected from scammers?

Do we pour billions into educating users not to click "yes" to every prompt they see?

Do we try and build a super-secure Operating System which, somehow, gives users complete freedom without exposing them to risk?

Do we hope that Google won't suddenly start extorting developers, users, and society as a whole?

Do we chase down and punish everyone who releases a scam app?

Do we stick an AI on every phone to detect scam apps and refuse to run them if they're dodgy?

I don't know the answers to any of these questions and - if I'm honest - I don't like asking them.



  1. Post by @Gargron
    View on Mastodon


    ↩︎


#android #google #rant #scam


Sensitive content

Pepe Coin News Today: Why This Trending Altcoin Is Targeting 8,000% Gains By January - Pepe Coin News today has the market buzzing, but analysts say the real breakout could com... - blockonomi.com/pepe-coin-news-… #pr

Why did books start being divided into chapters? A new history

Link: sydneyreviewofbooks.com/review…
Discussion: news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4…

Bet on UFC With ETH & USDC: Top MMA Crypto Sportsbooks - UFC remains one of the biggest draws in sports betting worldwide. From blockbuster pay-pe... - cryptodaily.co.uk/2025/08/bet-… #morenews

Ethereum Price Prediction: Joseph Lubin Confident in a ‘100x’ Rally and a BTC Flippening - Ethereum is trading at $4,464, up 0.36% in the last 24 hours, with daily trading v... - cryptonews.com/news/ethereum-p… #cryptocurrency #priceanalysis #ethereum

Top 5 Altcoins With 10x Potential to Watch Before the 2025 Altcoin Season Begins - With Bitcoin stabilizing above $110,000 and institutional adoption accelerating, the mark... - blockonomi.com/top-5-altcoins-… #pr

Eric Trump Doubles Down: ‘No Question’ Bitcoin Will Hit $1 Million - Eric Trump, co-founder of American Bitcoin (ABTC) and son of U.S. President Donald Trump,... - cryptonews.com/news/eric-trump… #bitcoinnews #erictrump #adoption #bitcoin

Ο Πρωθυπουργός υπόσχεται «φθηνότερη» ενέργεια και «ευκαιρίες» 13ωρης εργασίας thepressproject.gr/o-prothypou…

PC Gamer just posted:

'That was my first experience with PvP,' Naoki Yoshida's love for game design all started with a tragic Mario Brothers bait and switch

Lucy from Peanuts would love FF14 raids.

pcgamer.com/games/final-fantas…

#gamingNews

PCGamesN just posted:

New 'Morrowind in Elden Ring' mod has my attention, despite the poison swamps

After the huge success of Skyrim and the Oblivion Remake, one big question remains: Will Bethesda ever return to one of its most beloved but outdated RPGs? The Elder Scrolls 3: Morrowind is unquestionably a classic, but recommending it in 2025 comes with a giant list of caveats. There are, however, several fan-built alternatives. Tamriel Rebuilt ...

pcgamesn.com/elden-ring/elder-…

#gamingNews

Bitcoin Price Prediction: Why the Onchain ‘Buy the Dip’ Signal Could Lead to a Liquidity Hunt - Bitcoin is currently at $109,086, up 0.50% in the last 24 hours, with a daily trad... - cryptonews.com/news/bitcoin-pr… #cryptocurrency #priceanalysis #bitcoin

DSOGaming just posted:

Elden Ring Modder Is Porting the Entire World of Morrowind Into the Game

Now here is something really cool. Modder ‘InfernoPlus’ is currently working on a mod that aims to bring the whole world of The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind into Elden Ring. This mod has been in development for a few months, and below you can find a 15-minute gameplay video of it. The goal of this …

dsogaming.com/pc-performance-a…

#gamingNews

Sensitive content

PCGamesN just posted:

Ninja Gaiden 4's incredibly deep and intense combat has left me stunned

It’s been a long old wait for a new, mainline Ninja Gaiden game, but the pain will soon end. Ninja Gaiden 4 brings the action game series kicking (hacking) and screaming (slashing) into the 2020s with extra mechanics and a new protagonist alongside Ryu. But the biggest twist is that Team Ninja is enlisting the help of Platinum Games to create this new ...

pcgamesn.com/ninja-gaiden-4/in…

#gamingNews

California governor teases ‘Trump Corruption Coin’ in jab at MAGA memecoins - California Governor Gavin Newsom says his planned m... - cointelegraph.com/news/califor…

Red: A programming language inspired by REBOL

Link: github.com/red/red
Discussion: news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4…

VideoCardz just posted:

Samsung says “5 Inches can change everyday life”, launches world’s first 37 inch 4K monitor

Samsung launches world's first 37-Inch ViewFinity S8 Monitor Samsung has introduced a 37-inch model to its ViewFinity S8 lineup, positioned between the existing 32- and 43-inch versions. It is the...Keep on reading: Samsung says “5 Inches can change everyday life”, launches world’s first 37 inch 4K monitor

videocardz.com/newz/samsung-sa…

#gamingNews

Tether's Multi-Chain Empire: A Definitive Guide to the USDT Ecosystem - When you hear traders talk about "USDT," they may or may not be referencing a single digi... - cryptodaily.co.uk/2025/08/teth… #morenews

Trump’s Central Bank Theatrics Expose the Fed’s Myth of Independence - There’s plenty of uproar surrounding U.S. President Donald Trump’s recent pressure... - news.bitcoin.com/trumps-centra… #federalreserve #jeromepowell #donaldtrump #op-ed

VideoCardz just posted:

ZOTAC Zone Pro to feature Ryzen HX 370, 7″ OLED screen, 32GB RAM and Manjaro Linux

ZOTAC Zone Pro announced at Gamescom High-end specs, high-end price? ZOTAC has been quiet about its ZONE handheld series. The company’s last system launched just weeks before MSI announced the...Keep on reading: ZOTAC Zone Pro to feature Ryzen HX 370, 7″ OLED screen, 32GB RAM and Manjaro Linux

videocardz.com/newz/zotac-zone…

#gamingNews

While Ethereum Climbs Toward $5,500, Dogecoin and XYZVerse (XYZ) Battle for $1 Milestone - Ethereum is catching attention as its price moves closer to $5,500, but other coins are m... - cryptodaily.co.uk/2025/08/whil… #morenews

India Jails 14 for Life in Crypto Extortion Case Involving Cops, Ex-MLA - An Indian anti-corruption court has sentenced 14 men to life in prison for the 201... - cryptonews.com/news/india-jail… #altcoinnews #cryptocrime #crime #india

TheGamer just posted:

These Classic PS2 Horror Games Are Still Severely Underrated

These excellent PlayStation 2 horror games may have been long forgotten, but they're still terrifyingly good!

thegamer.com/horror-games-play…

#gamingNews

Crypto for the People: Best Meme Coins That Can Offer More Than Just Hype - In crypto, people often talk about tokens in terms of “utility” — governance rights, paym... - cryptodaily.co.uk/2025/08/cryp… #morenews

Experts See LayerBrett Surpassing Shiba Inu And Cardano, Calling It PEPE 2.0 With Rare 10,000% Profit Potential - In crypto, a 10,000% profit run isn’t just rare, it’s practically mythical. Only a handfu... - blockonomi.com/experts-see-lay… #pr

Top Cryptocurrencies To Buy Now: Layer Brett, Solana, Chainlink, and Shiba Inu - The world of cryptocurrency never goes to sleep and there are always new investors seekin... - cryptodaily.co.uk/2025/08/top-… #morenews

TheGamer just posted:

Tips And Tricks To Play Wuyang In Overwatch 2

From the best perks based on your playstyle to general tips for healing and damage, here's everything you'll need to play Wuyang in Overwatch 2.

thegamer.com/overwatch-2-wuyan…

#gamingNews

Given Trump’s Pro-Crypto Stance, Is it Time to Fully Ditch Gold in Favor of Bitcoin? - Given the Trump administration’s vocal and demonstrated support for crypto, some investor... - coindesk.com/markets/2025/08/3… #equities #markets #hedging #bonds #gold #news #btc

Nintendo Life just posted:

Sonic "Love Letter" Rollin' Rascal Announced For Switch 2

Keep on rollin'.Last February, you might recall how our retro-focused sibling site Time Extension highlighted a new high-speed game called Rollin' Rascal.At the time, this Kickstarter project (drawing inspiration from 3D Sonic platformers and even Mario) had just reached its Nintendo Switch goal, and now, well over a year later, the development team Curiomatic has ...

nintendolife.com/news/2025/08/…

#gamingNews

Rick Beato is right to rant about music copyright strikes

Link: savingcountrymusic.com/rick-be…
Discussion: news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4…

The Hard Times just posted:

Mocktail Perfect For Man Who Doesn’t Want To Drink, But Still Wants To Spend $18

ARLINGTON, Va. — Local restaurant the Green Garden began serving mocktails which are perfect for the person who doesn’t want to drink, but still wants…

thehardtimes.net/culture/mockt…

#gamingNews

Press briefing for Good-Neighborliness, Friendship and Cooperation Commission of SCO held at media center en.people.cn/n3/2025/0831/c900…

Cardano & Dogecoin Lag While Traders Eye Layer Brett After Analysts Project 140x Gains Before 2026 - Are you tired of watching giants like Cardano (ADA) and Dogecoin (DOGE) crawl forward wit... - cryptodaily.co.uk/2025/08/card… #morenews

Just checked the tank—pH is holding steady at 7.2, temperature at 74°F. Shrimp are grazing on biofilm near the heater, looking active. Molting season means I’ll dose calcium tomorrow. Always a good sign when the cherry shrimps are pairing off near the moss balls. Nature’s tiny rhythm keepers.

New research reveals longevity gains slowing, life expectancy of 100 unlikely

Link: lafollette.wisc.edu/news/new-r…
Discussion: news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4…

Gamespot just posted:

Kill Bill 4K Blu-Ray Editions Get Limited-Time Price Cuts At Amazon

Quentin Tarantino 4K Blu-ray Deals Kill Bill Vol. 1 & 2, Pulp Fiction, Inglourious Basterds, and more. See at Amazon Amazon has limited-time deals on the 4K Blu-ray editions of Kill Bill Vol. 1 and Kill Bill Vol. 2. The acclaimed Quentin Tarantino saga starring Uma Thurman finally made its way to 4K Blu-ray earlier this year alongside Jackie ...

gamespot.com/articles/kill-bil…

#gamingNews

U.S. Centers for Disease Control in Turmoil from MAHA Push; Peter Thiel Crony Jim O'Neill Now in Charge eir.news/2025/08/news/u-s-cent…

Analysts Eye New Presale Surge as Avalanche and Polkadot Cool Off in Late Q3 Trading - The crypto market is experiencing an exciting period as the Q3 draws to a close. Avalanch... - blockonomi.com/analysts-eye-ne… #pr

Sensitive content

Autobranche - VW in Brasilien zu Strafe wegen sklavenähnlicher Arbeit in den 70er und 80er Jahren verurteilt


Der Volkswagen-Konzern ist in Brasilien wegen sklavenähnlicher Arbeitsbedingungen in den 70er- und 80er-Jahren zu Schadensersatz verurteilt worden.
Autobranche - VW in Brasilien zu Strafe wegen sklavenähnlicher Arbeit in den 70er und 80er Jahren verurteilt

N. E. Felibata 👽 reshared this.

Ripple Partner Amina Bank Deepens Circle Alliance Ties to Advance Regulated Stablecoins - Amina Bank is cementing its dominance in regulated stablecoin finance with bold ne... - news.bitcoin.com/ripple-partne… #stablecoin #ripplexrp #featured #circle #bank

Verstöße gegen Parteiengesetz - Mehr als Hälfte der Strafgelder im Bundestag entfallen auf AfD


Die im Bundestag vertretenen Parteien haben seit 2017 wegen Verstößen gegen das Parteiengesetz etwa 1,8 Millionen Euro zahlen müssen. Rund 1,1 Millionen Euro davon entfielen auf die AfD.
Verstöße gegen Parteiengesetz - Mehr als Hälfte der Strafgelder im Bundestag entfallen auf AfD

N. E. Felibata 👽 reshared this.

Death toll from Gaza Strip's struggle for livelihood rises to 2,203, with 16,228 injured saba.ye/en/news3544362.htm

Sensitive content

Rock, Paper, Shotgun just posted:

The Sunday Papers

Sundays are for finally, after months of waiting, getting your siblings to come round and collect their shares of the bequeathed photos and other familial bric-a-brac that’s been leaving a dust smell in your spare room. Yet not getting mad about it, as you know their tardiness only confirms what you knew all along: you really are the most responsible one. Take that warm, cosy smugness to the ...

rockpapershotgun.com/the-sunda…

#gamingNews

Metaplanet’s Bitcoin strategy faces fundraising crunch as stock sinks: Report - Metaplanet’s stock has plunged 54% since mid-June, ... - cointelegraph.com/news/metapla…

Ethereum, XRP and a New Presale Token Lead Analyst Picks for Best Crypto to Buy in Q4 - Analysts agree that Ethereum, XRP and a new presale token are some of the most compelling... - blockonomi.com/ethereum-xrp-an… #pr