Mastodon is decentralised.

I have 45,465 followers on my single-person instance.

Of those, 13,180 are on mastodon.social.

So roughly 30% of my followers are on mastodon.social.

Also, I follow 11,392 people.

Of those, 1,864 are on mastodon.social.

If mastodon.social blocks my instance, I lose 30% of my followers and I’m forced to stop following 1,864 people.

If my instance blocks mastodon.social, I lose 30% of my followers and I’m forced to stop following 1,864 people.

Mastodon is decentralised.

#mastodon #federation #fediverse #decentralisation

This entry was edited (1 month ago)
Unknown parent

mastodon - Link to source

Aral Balkan

@martijn This is also true.

If only web hosts were more interoperable. Hopefully we’ll be able to build a good abstraction layer for Domain for this on the Small Web although I’m starting out with Hetzner too because it’s the easiest to use (API) and excellent value for money (we need to charge for the servers but I don’t want us or others to charge so much that it’s untenable for people. Maybe once we’ve proven the model works we can get governments/EU to take their heads out of their asses and support us from the common purse. Given what I’ve seen in the last decade with politicians and the EU, I’m not holding my breath for that and nor am I basing the system on it.)

in reply to Aral Balkan

@martijn Yes, anyone (including me) can easily fall into that trap. Convenience (low cost, ease of use, etc.) unfortunately often leads to hidden dependencies and a concentration on a few infrastructure and toolset providers somewhere down in the tech stack.

But even though decentralization will probably never be 100%, it always makes sense to think about it, try it, and be aware of it.

in reply to Andreas F.

@Andreas F. @Sexybiggetje🐖 @Aral Balkan I run a friendica, hubzilla, and mastodon, the hubzilla and friendica both have a lot of protocols they speak so between then they interface with the vast majority of the fediverse. I personally prefer long format macro blogging and hence mostly use my friendica node, but many prefer the others. But point being that being connected to multiple networks and being able to connect to people on any of them provides a greater degree of diversity and less dependency upon one.
Unknown parent

mastodon - Link to source

Aral Balkan

@mastodonmigration I would express it differently: if a network has economies of scale baked in, it is centralised, even if you don’t know it yet. So it was with the web, so it is with email, and ditto for ActivityPub/Mastodon. Federation is better than nothing but there is nothing in the protocol or in its big-tech stack implementations in the popular clients to prevent centralisation. The best tool we had was social pressure and that lever was summarily disposed of early on when the only folks who could have used it decided not to.