[Resolved] Looking for recommendations -- CD Ripper
Hey hey, I have been using Sound Juicer on my Ubuntu 24 / KDE 5 PC and it works, but it doesn't handle the tags for my MP3 files very nicely. I've also used abcde, at the terminal, and that can be better but it takes a lot finessing at the CLI to get the result I want.
Is there a better CD ripper application that will run on Ubuntu and can make setting the MP3 tags dead simple?
Thanks for any ideas!
Edit: Fixed a typo
ETA: Asunder looks good, does what I need and works well on my PC. Thanks for everyone's ideas and help!
This entry was edited (1 day ago)
Nanook
in reply to perishthethought • •kata1yst
in reply to Nanook • • •GitHub - whipper-team/whipper: Python CD-DA ripper preferring accuracy over speed
GitHubperishthethought
in reply to Nanook • • •Hrrrmmm, yes. I'm starting to think there is no currently maintained, FOSS application that will both rip and tag MP3 files for me now.
Whipper seems to only outputs FLACs.
FRE:AC doesn't display correctly on my PC.
I'm going to try Asunder next, but it too isn't maintained, it seems.
If only I could go write my own...
kyub
in reply to perishthethought • • •I use whipper. It's a command-line application but it's easy to use and works great every single time.
At first you should let it analyze your drive which is the only step more involved. Here's a mini tutorial for that I wrote for myself but you can also read it on the project page where it's probably more up to date:
And just as an example, here's my
~/.config/whipper/whipper.conf
:Nanook
in reply to kyub • — (Shoreline, WA, USA) •Eldritch
in reply to perishthethought • • •perishthethought
in reply to Eldritch • • •MentalEdge
in reply to perishthethought • • •Looking up Picard's instructions... They recommend whipper, as others have done in the thread.
It can do the tagging for you, but it's important to note that music CDs do not contain metadata.
All the rippers that exist, look up what the CD is online, based on stuff like number of tracks, their lengths, and order. iTunes was the ripping software everyone used back in the day, because Apple made and maintained the first extensive database that could be used to automatically tag ripped music.
Modern rippers typically rely on MusicBrainz (like Picard).
As such there is no 100% reliable auto-tagging ripper, because a disc might match more than one album, or not be in the database. Such cases will always require manual intervention.