Please tell your friends about federated social media site that speaks several fediverse protocols thus serving as a hub uniting them, hubzilla.eskimo.com, also check out friendica.eskimo.com, federated
macroblogging social media site, mastodon.eskimo.com a federated microblogging site, and yacy.eskimo.com an uncensored federated search engine. All Free!
I kind of hate this now. It's a plane crash, it's sad, they're all sad. It was avoidable, they're all avoidable. This particular one shouldn't be that special, but once you hear the radio recording it's hard to shake it.
@Caleb James DeLisle Given that parts of the tail were found three miles from the crash site there is the question of was there even an elevator or was the turbulence sufficient to detach it causing the dive?
I think the best current hypothesis is: 1. Ice buildup caused tail stall 2. Downward pitch caused over-speed 3. Diving into thunderstorm caused more ice, tail remained stalled 4. Over-speed caused mach tuck making it impossible to pull back even if the tail were to recover 5. Over-speed, ice, and turbulence while holding the stick all the way back eventually caused the elevator to snap off
My personal gut feeling as a non-pilot is that the die was set from the moment the dive began.
@Caleb James DeLisle There is much that is just conjecture and because there was no flight data recorder and nobody survived, most remain that way. The left elevator did break up and parts were spread from 3.8 to 1.3 miles from the crash site. What proceeded that is conjecture. We don't know if they had operational radar and if so why they did not avoid the storm. It's tragic. The FAA does not know if the horizontal stabilizer was lost because of the descent or because of turbulence, so if they don't know I'm not going to conjecture.
If there was unreported damage to the stabilizer then it is possible, but generally speaking, a plane is not supposed to lose control surfaces when it's flying inside of its allowed speed - even in extreme turbulence. Those are kind of built for worst realistic scenario.
But once you are in over-speed, then you're - by definition - outside of any scenario the plane was designed for, and they went into overspeed very early in the dive.
Nanook
in reply to Caleb James DeLisle • •Caleb James DeLisle
in reply to Nanook • • •I think the best current hypothesis is:
1. Ice buildup caused tail stall
2. Downward pitch caused over-speed
3. Diving into thunderstorm caused more ice, tail remained stalled
4. Over-speed caused mach tuck making it impossible to pull back even if the tail were to recover
5. Over-speed, ice, and turbulence while holding the stick all the way back eventually caused the elevator to snap off
My personal gut feeling as a non-pilot is that the die was set from the moment the dive began.
Nanook
in reply to Caleb James DeLisle • •Caleb James DeLisle
in reply to Nanook • • •If there was unreported damage to the stabilizer then it is possible, but generally speaking, a plane is not supposed to lose control surfaces when it's flying inside of its allowed speed - even in extreme turbulence. Those are kind of built for worst realistic scenario.
But once you are in over-speed, then you're - by definition - outside of any scenario the plane was designed for, and they went into overspeed very early in the dive.